Two levels of index

Three levels of index

Development stage Xijiang MiaoVillage (%)

The stable stage Hongyan Village (%)

Decline stage Butterfly Valley (%)

Political influence evaluation index

Cadre corruption

41.2

80.3

64.0

Policy changes

73.5

73.5

79.8

Understand policy

73.9

83.9

77.2

Economic impact evaluation index

Poverty gap

83.0

65.4

55.1

Rent prices

73.5

65.6

75.5

The land problem

74.1

70.9

67.8

To increase the income of farmers

62.5

79.0

83.8

Environmental impact evaluation index

Sanitary conditions

95.4

99.3

99.6

Infrastructure

99.1

99.4

100.0

Traffic jam

62.2

86.3

89.0

The ecological environment

84.8

97.9

82.9

Cultural impact evaluation index

Outdated customs and bad habits

78.6

82.6

84.5

External conflict

67.1

88.0

77.0

Family and marriage

68.9

91.1

72.9

Religious conflict

84.4

87.0

84.6

The crime rate

70.4

98.2

73.7

Technology information

74.2

86.0

76.4

Neighborhood disputes

61.7

80.0

93.4

Moral standards

80.2

80.8

89.1